The scene as the epic opens is that Odysseus is kept by Calypso on her
island in her hopes that he will be her husband. Since Poseidon is away
receiving hecatombs in Ethiopia, and all the other gods want Odysseus to
return home, Zeus grants Athena permission for his return, and sends
Hermes to tell Calypso. Athena goes to Telemachos, Odysseus’ son, now come
to young manhood and, in the form of Mentor, instructs him what to do.
Accordingly, he calls an assembly and tells the all the suitors that have
been living his house for four years, eating up his livelihood, to go
home. Disregarding the advice of an elder prophet, they tell Telemachos
that they are not leaving until his mother Penelope chooses one of them to
marry. She does not want to marry any of them, and hence has delayed
choosing any for four years. Telemachos requests the gods to judge on his
behalf, then goes to Eurykleia, his old nurse and keeper of the house, to
prepare everything so he can go on a voyage with twenty of his companions
to ask what happened to his father, but not to tell his mother.
Athena-Mentor promised to procure the ship and companions, which she does,
and she accompanies him to the first stage, Nestor, after which she
disappears as a bird. Nestor said he did not know what happened to
Odysseus, but suggested he visit Menelaos in Sparta. This being Athena’s
instruction, he does. Menelaos receives him well, and Helen appears as a
mild, dutiful wife. After relating his travels after sacking Troy, and how
Agamemnon was killed by a friend who seduced his wife, says that he heard
from the Old Man of the Sea that Odysseus was alive, but trapped on
Calypso’s island.
Meanwhile, Hermes tells Calypso to release Odysseus on Zeus’ orders, and
she complains that the male gods take whatever mortal women they like, but
whenever a goddess or nymph takes one, Zeus prevents it. Then she tells
Odysseus, who weeps every day, longing to go back home and to his wife,
that if he does not want to stay with her and become immortal, she will
let him leave. So he builds a raft, and she gives him material for a sail,
and after twenty days of sailing, he comes in sight of land. This is when
Poseidon returns, and he calls up a storm. After several days and hard
swimming, Odysseus makes it to shore with the help of the veil of a nymph,
and then, going away from the shore to somewhere warmer, he collapses into
sleep in the leaves of a dense copse of trees.
Naked, the next morning he goes as a suppliant (carrying a branch with
leaves to cover himself) to the young daughter of the king of the island
of Phaiakia where he landed. Athena had stirred her up to do the laundry
with her maids. Nausicaä received him well, gave him clothes, and had him
ride in the ox-cart until she got close to land—since it would be
unseemly to have made personal friends with a man. (Although she wished
that he could be her husband instead of the young men courting her, since
he looked godlike after his bath and Athena’s added glamor.) Posing as a
young girl, Athena met him at the city gate and when he said he was
looking for the king’s house, she took him there. They were feasting, and,
unnoticed, he went up to the queen as Nausicaä advised and clasped her
knees as a suppliant, asking that they take him home. After asking him how
he got the clothes he was wearing (since she saw that she had woven the
material herself). He told he had escaped from Calypso and was
raft-wrecked, and how virtuously their daughter had received him. They
agreed to take him back in their fast ships, both because he was a
suppliant and because it was their habit to provide passage for any.
But first, the next day they feasted. King Alkinoös noticed that at the
songs of Troy his guest cried, and said that they had had enough songs,
lets do sport. So they showed off how athletic they were for their guest,
but when one of them insulted Odysseus, he took a heavier discus than any
they had been using and overthrew all their shots by not a little, and
said he would not at all afraid to take any of them on, except not the
eldest son of Alkinoös (it is unbecoming to fight with one’s host), and
the raft left him out of conditioning for a foot race. Then Alkinoös said
they should show of how skilled dancers they were, and Odysseus was
properly impressed and said so to Alkinoös, who was pleased and offered
Odysseus gifts (plus told the man to gift Odysseus a gift to compensate
for his earlier insult). At the feast that evening, Alkinoös insisted tell
them who he was and how he came here. Odysseus identified himself as
“wide-famed” Odysseus, and told his story, enthralling them with his
telling.
After sacking Troy, they sacked the city of the Kikonians. Odysseus
wanted to leave immediately, but his men wanted to wait until the next
day, but the next day the supporters of the city came and attacked them,
and while they held their own in the morning, they had to flee. Then they
came to the island of the Lotus Eaters, who were friendly, but the men who
ate their lotus wanted to do nothing but stay and eat lotus, so Odysseus
had to forcibly carry them back to the ship and restrain them. Next they
came to the island of the Cyclops, and wanting to see if he could get any
guest presents, Odysseus went to see if there were any people. They found
the cave of Polyphemos, and ate some of his goat cheese and waited. In the
evening he came back, put his flock of sheep into the cave, and sealed the
entrance with a stone. Then, seeing Odysseus and his men, he ate two of
them. In the morning, he did the same, but Odysseus had his men sharpen a
thick tree cut into a pole into a point. The cyclops ate another two men,
and when asked, Odysseus said his name was “Nobody”. They got him drunk on
wine, and while he was sleeping, they drove the tree-pole into his eye,
blinding him. Hearing his bellowing, the other cyclops came, and he said
that “Nobody was hurting him”, so they so left. Odysseus roped the sheep
together by threes and roped a man under the middle one, and himself
grabbed the stomach of a large ram. The cyclops felt the tops of the
sheep, but did not notice the men, and so they left with the sheep. Once
they had sailed out of range, Odysseus, against the wishes of his men
gloated that he had escaped (he would not get glory for the deed if no one
knew), but the cyclops threw a huge boulder that washed them back to
shore. This happened a second time, but they were washed back to the rest
of the ships and left.
They came next to the island of Aiolos, whose eponoymous king sent them
off with a bag of the north, east, and south winds tied up, so they would
have good winds. But just as they were nearing Ithaca, Odysseus fell
asleep, and his men thought the bag had gifts in it, which they resented,
since they had done most of the work themselves. On opening the bag, the
other winds sprang out, and a storm blew up, which pushed them back to
Aiolos. This time Aiolos told them to leave and refused to help them
because obviously the gods were against them.
After that they came to Circe’s island. The initial scouting party that
Odysseus sent was invited into her house, given a drink, and then she
turned them into pigs with her wand, except for the leader, who,
suspecting treachery, had stayed outside. Hermes told Odysseus what she
was doing, gave her a root that would prevent them being turned into pigs,
and instructed him what to do. They met Circe, but this time she could not
turn them into pigs. Then Circle wanted Odysseus to sleep with her, but he
said he could not possibly do it willingly unless he got his men back.
This she did, and, following Hermes’ instructions, he did. Circe said they
should stay with her until they were well-rested, but after a year of
well-resting, Odysseus’ men said they had to leave. Circe helped them
leave (she had also wanted Odysseus as a husband), but said Odysseus
needed to go to the south where the ocean ended and Hades began, to hear
what the Athenian prophet Teiresias had to tell him. So he did, and he
offered the sacrifice of a black sheep and a white sheep, filling two pits
with water, the blood, and white barley on top. He held back the shades
until Teiresias came and drank. Then he prophesied and told them
everything he had to, in particular not to eat Helios’ cattle. After
Teiresias went away, he let other shades drink of the blood, and when they
did, their memories returned and he talked with them. His mother told him
she died out of sadness for him. Achilles said, when Odysseus said that
his glory was widely known, that being a slave and alive was better than
being dead and having glory, but was happy that his son had made a name
for himself. Agamemnon told how he had been killed by his wife and her
lover, and advised Odysseus not to trust women. (It seems that perhaps the
heroes were not shades, but that is not made clear in the text.) Then they
sailed back to Circe’s island and she gave them more provisions.
Circe warned Odysseus about the Sirens, so he stopped up his men’s ears
with beeswax, but had them lash him to the mast so that he could
experience it. They music is not described, but their words are
flattering, telling him to stay so they can sing to him about his
greatness, and also to give him knowledge of all things that happened
after Troy. After that, they had to avoid Charybdis’s whirlpool, and
Odysseus prepared to attack the six-headed Scylla on the other side, but
was too absorbed with avoiding Charybdis that he was too late and six of
his men were eaten. Then they came to the island with Helios’ cattle, but
the winds turned against them for over a month. Odysseus prevented them
from raiding the cattle until their supplies were gone, but after that,
when he had gone off to pray, they killed some cattle and ate it. Odysseus
ate none, but Teiresias’ prophesy was that even if he did not, if his men
did, he would suffer hardships and have a poor homecoming. The winds
turned and the sailed, but Helios asked Zeus to punish them, and Zeus
waited until their ship was in the middle of the ocean, with no land
anywhere, and hit it with a thunderbolt. All the men perished, but
Odysseus managed to cling onto the rudder. He was blown back by a storm to
Charybdis and Scylla, and luckily for him Scylla was apparently sleeping,
but Charybdis sucked down his raft, and he had to hang on to the branch of
the olive tree that grew over her until sundown, when she spit up his
raft. Eventually he drifted onto Calypso’s island, where she forcibly kept
him because she wanted him for a husband.
The Phaiakians were silent for a while after he finished, amazed at his
story. Then Alkinoös said each king, including himself, should give him a
tripod and cauldron, in addition to the clothes and talent of gold they
had given him in the morning, and they all assented readily. That night
they piled all his gifts in the ship and made a bed for him in the middle,
and rowed him to Ithaca (their ships were able to get to their destination
in only a day). They unloaded his gifts, then carried his bed with him
still sleeping onto the beach, and sailed back. Poseidon, having
complained to Zeus that the Phaiakians had delivered the man he did not
want delivered, asked Zeus for punishment, and Zeus said that he should
turn the ship to stone in sight of the harbor, which he did. Then the
Phaiakians decided not to offer conveyance to outsiders any more, which
was Poseidon’s desire.
Athena prevented Odysseus from recognizing his homeland, and when he
asked her in the form she took where he was, and she said Ithaca, he did
not believe her, until she revealed herself as Athena. Then they hid his
gifts in a sacred cave, and Athena told him to go to the house of his
shepherd Eumaios, while she arranged for Telemachos, who was returning
from his voyage, from being killed by the suitors who were waiting to
ambush his ship. Athena tapped Odysseus with her wand and changed him into
an old man with dirty clothing. Eumaios indicated that he loved his master
Odysseus, who had always treated him well, and was displeased that the
suitors were eating up his estate. Odysseus told Eumaios that he was a man
of wealth from Crete, but who had fallen on hard times, having been
kidnapped to be sold as a slave, but having just escaped from the ship
while they were sleeping.
After Telemachos returned safely, Mentor-Athena told him to go to Eumaois
the shepherd. Odysseus told him a simplified version of his lie, but then
Athena came and transformed him back to his normal vigor. Telemachos,
noticing the impossible change, thought he was a god and wanted to
sacrifice to him, but he identified himself as Odysseus, his father, and
gave proof. Then he told Telemachos what to do when he came to the house,
and to put all the weapons in the hall into storage on the pretext that
the smoke was damaging them. Then Athena changed him back to an old man.
Telemachos went down to the house in the city to tell his mother that he
had arrived safely back from his trip (no one thought he had the gumption
to do it, and certainly no one thought he would come back; Athena had him
do it to make a man of him and to build his reputation).
Odysseus went down with Eumaios when he brought the fattened porkers for
the daily feast. He was insulted by his goat-herder at the well. He came
into the house as a guest, and Telemachos gave him a table and something
to eat. At the feast, the suitors insulted him, and one of the leaders
threw a footstool at him. Penelope wanted to question him, but he said she
should do it after the feast, in private, since it would be more proper,
and she said what he said was true. He gave her a story, and said that he
had seen Odysseus raiding on the mainland, and it would be not long until
he returned. Penelope refused to believe it, nor had she believed the
prophet-guest Telemachos had conveyed to Ithaca, who said that the omens
indicated Odysseus’ return. She said she would have him bathed, but
Odysseus said that he was too embarrassed to be bathed by any young woman,
but he would accept a bath from an old woman. So Eurykleia brought out
water to bathe him, and she noticed the scar on the knee, which he got
from a wild boar unsuccessfully trying to escape his spear, and she
recognized him. She tried to tell Penelope, but he silenced her, asking if
she wanted to get him killed. He could not sleep, trying to scheme a way
to kill the suitors as only one man, so Athena came and chided him, saying
that she was fighting for him, and it did not matter how many were against
him, she would see to it that he was victorious.
The next day had more insults, and the suitors riled up the resident
guest to threaten old vagabond Odysseus, but Odysseus hit him so hard with
just one punch that his ears bled and he lay on the ground. The suitors
lauded his performance, but also mocked Telemachos for have a guest who
did not work (the other guest at least ran messages). Odysseus scoped out
Eumaios, and the ox-herder Philoitios, and found that they would fight for
him, and he identified himself as Odysseus and promised to find them wives
and increase their status from slaves to Telemachos’ companions. Penelope
had decided to marry the suitor who could string Odysseus’ bow and shoot
through twelve iron axeheads (they apparently had a hole somewhere).
Telemachos dug a trench and set up the axheads perfectly straight with a
string, despite never having see the contest before. It took four tries,
but Telemachos would have strung the bow had not Odysseus warned him off.
Then all the suitors tried and failed to string the great bow of horn.
Then Odysseus asked to try it, and they were angry with him. Penelope said
to let him try, it’s not like he was going to take her off an marry her if
he managed to do it, but the suitors said that they would be embarrassed
if an old vagabond managed to do something they, the best young men of
Ithaca and the surrounds, could not. But Eumaios brought it to him, and
then told Eurykleia the housekeeper to put all the women (including
Penelope) upstairs and bar the halls, and Philoitios wound rope around the
door from outside, and then returned.
Odysseus looked the bow over carefully to make sure it was still in good
condition (a horn bow can break if not handled properly), prompting
remarks and jeers from the suitors that the vagabond seemed to know what
he was doing. Then he strung it with ease, sent an arrow through the
axeheads. Then he spread out the arrows before him. He shot Antinoös, the
most insolent suitor first. They were stunned, and Odysseus identified
himself as Odysseus returned. Then the suitor who had promised the most
gifts to Penelope in exchange for her had (but who was sleeping with one
of the housemaids, and this housemaid was quite disrespect to the old,
vagabond Odysseus-guest) said that they had been taking orders Antinoös,
who had paid for his crime with his life, and asked Odysseus to let them
go and they would each pay him back twelve oxen [there were about 100
suitors, so that would be quite a herd]. Odysseus said that they had
disrespected his wife, disrespected him as a guest, acted highly
improperly as guests (and, unstated, but they were also trying to usurp
his kingship or ruin it so that Telemachos would not be able to take
Odysseus’ place), and he would not accept all their fathers’ treasure.
Then they drew their swords and he started firing. Eumaios asked about
getting armor and Odysseus said to do it before he ran out of arrows.
Afterwards they strapped on the armor. Now the insolent goat-herder had
climbed over the wall and come back with a handful of weapons and armor
that he passed down to them. So Odysseus told Eumaios and Philoitios to
wait for him to make a second trip, then tie his hands and feet behind his
back and leave him off the ground with a rope, which they did. Coming
back, they were all in a line, and the suitors three six or seven javelins
at the four of them, but Athena caused them to miss wildly. They threw in
returned and killed four. This repeated, with another four dying. Then
they fought with the sword. At the end, one of the suitors who did not
agree with what they suitors had been doing, came up an clasped his hands,
saying that he participated in none of it, and he was their seer. Odysseus
said that if that was so, he must have prayed against his return, and
beheaded him. Then the singer ran up and clasped his knees saying that he
had been forced to sing and play his harp, and Telemachos vouched for him,
and also said they should spare the house-herald, if he not already been
killed. (The herald had been hiding under a ox hide under a chair and had
gone unnoticed.)
Odysseus summoned Eurykleia who rejoiced over the Odysseus, his hands and
front spattered in blood, with the heaps of dead suitors all around, but
Odysseus stopped her. He had her bring all the traitorous housemaids,
which were twelve in all, and made them wipe down the chairs and clean the
room, while Telemachos, Eumaios, and Philoitios cleared the bodies away.
Then, told Telemachos to kill the twelve women with the edge of the sword,
but he thought that was too good for them, so he put them in a narrow
single-file passageway, and hung them, each of them putting her head in
the loop like a doomed bird. Their feet struggled, but not for long.
Finally, Eurykleia could tell Penelope that Odysseus had returned, and
Penelope told her off, saying it was only Eurykleia’s old age that
prevented her from a more severe punishment. But Eurykleia said that she
had seen Odysseus’ scare and knew it was him. So she rejoiced briefly, and
went downstairs. She looked at Odysseus for a long time. Then she gave
instructions to give make up Odysseus’ own bed and bring it down for this
“Odysseus” to sleep on. Odysseus got angry, and said that that would be
difficult, since he had carved the headboard out of a tree, which was in
the center of the bedroom that he built around it, so unless someone had
sawed under it, bringing it down was impossible. Since no man had seen
Odysseus’ bed, she accepted this as proof and embraced him. Their bed was
made ready, and they went in and enjoyed themselves in love, and then told
each other their stories. Meanwhile, Odysseus had told the three to have
the singer play music and to dance along with the housemaids, as if a
wedding were taking place, so no one would miss the suitors.
Then, next morning (and Athena delayed Dawn’s rising at the edge of the
world so Odysseus and Penelope could have more time together and still
sleep well), Odysseus told Penelope to go to her rooms upstairs and stay
there. He and the other three went to his father, Laertes, who had a villa
outside of town with a large, well-kept orchard. Laertes did not recognize
Odysseus, but Odysseus could not hide his identity from his father long
because of the old man’s grief and revealed himself. Laertes said to prove
it, so Odysseus showed him his scar and his father rejoiced. The family of
Laertes’ head servant came in, and he and his six sons, young men,
rejoiced to see his return, and they ate lunch. Meanwhile, the fathers of
the suitors held an assembly of the people and asked for help avenging
their murders. The old prophet said that they should have listened to him
earlier and kept their sons from abusing the hospitality of Odysseus’
house. About half the people agreed that the suitors deserved what they
got, but the other half put on armor and went to Laertes’ villa. So the
twelve men (including the old Laertes and his servant Dolion) got on their
armor. Odysseus urged Telemachos to have courage, who said that it was not
likely he who was going to lack it, prompting Laertes to rejoice
that his son and grandson were arguing over who had more courage. Then the
fight started, but Odysseus’ side (with Athena’s help) put the other side
to flight. When they turned to flee, Odysseus let out a great cry and
started to chase them, but Athena stopped him. So they swore oaths of
friendship and allegiance to him.
The Odyssey is surprisingly different from the Iliad,
and to my mind lacking in the greatness of the Iliad, so much so
that it seems unlikely to me (and to Lattimore) that the same person wrote
them, although clearly Odyssey comes from the same bardic
tradition. The Iliad only really involves a few days of
fighting, and only several weeks in the entire text. It focuses on
Achilles’ anger and desire for honor, and what the consequences are. But
within each book, some character makes a decision. Furthermore, the poetry
is more elegant, and the metaphors are just astounding. The Odyssey
has none of this; no character has an effective decision, most of it being
on rails by Athena, who mostly tells them what to do. Odysseus does make
decisions, but the nothing of the process is shown, nor are the
consequences tied to it. Certainly at the island of the Cyclops, Odysseus’
greed gets him (and some of his men) into trouble, and his hubris at
boasting of his accomplishment not only almost kill him then, but allow
Polyphemus to tell Poseidon, his father, who had blinded him, and thus
made an enemy of the god of the sea when his return is over the sea. Apart
from that, Odysseus mostly has no choice. In fact, the narration is mostly
“this, and this, and then that” and lots of intervention from deities.
From a modern perspective it is easy to see that “circumspect Penelope”,
Odysseus’ wife, remains faithful to him, but he spends a year sleeping
with Circe and then eight years sleeping with Calypso. Here I find an
interesting contrast with the Iliad, which makes it clear that
women of conquered cities are made into household slave-workers, and the
prettier ones become concubines of the men (really, high status men), or
rather, sex slaves, since they did not have choice in the matter. But in
the Odyssey, the situation is reversed. Here, Odysseus has no
power. He is forced to sleep with Circe to get his men turned back from
pigs (and, indeed, Hermes instructs him to not refuse her), and then she
beguiles them so that they apparently forget how quickly time passes. She
wants a Odysseus as a husband, but manipulates the perception of time to
keep him. Calypso is even worse, who straight-up keeps him by force, and
essentially forces him to play husband, even though she wants him to
choose her. So here it is that the women have the power (being goddesses,
albeit minor) and it is the high-born man that is the sex slave. It is far
from obvious to me that this was intended, but it certainly a very
noticeable change.
On his return, Odysseus is one man against a hundred, which provides an
opportunity for tension on how to accomplish this. Unfortunately, this
potential is squandered, because Athena does everything for him, and
Penelope even unknowingly sets up the scenario whereby he can get a weapon
in the hall. Contrast with the scene in the Iliad where Diomedes
and Odysseus go to spy out the Trojans. Sure, they ask for Athena’s help,
but the poem has them chasing down the Trojan counter-spy, and
interrogating him, and then the tension of how many to slaughter in their
sleep, risking discovery and disaster, and when to leave while they still
can. Odysseus on his return just has to bite down his anger and vengeance,
and endure mockery from unworthy guests, and we even see very little of
that.
To modern eyes, the mass killing of the suitors can seem excessive, but
it in a world where you pretty much had to make your own justice—the king
would have been responsible, but Odysseus was the king, but did not have
any hard power—you had to throw out people invading your home yourself.
Furthermore, the suitors were not just uninvited, unwanted, and violating
the responsibilities of being a good guest. Marrying Penelope would give
them a claim to the throne (Menelaos was king of Sparta because he married
Helen), and since Telemachos had come of age (thus being a claimant to the
throne), despoiling his property reduced his ability to pursue his claim
even further than his lack of power to dictate what happened in his own
house. If Odysseus had accepted the twelve oxen each, he would have risked
rival claimants to the throne, in addition to the severe violations of his
honor by other men pursuing his wife, sleeping his housemaids (it seems
some were willing, and others were not, but all inappropriate in that age;
presumably sleeping with the housemaid of the lady you are pursuing for
marriage is out of bounds, too), and despoiling his property. Since there
is no law, or one could say that Odysseus is recovering his ability to be
the law/justice for the community, starting with himself, he does not have
a lot of option. And the suitors know it; in an honor culture, their acts
were so dishonoring that they could expect harsh punishment.
There is another potential tension which is squandered: Odysseus may be
morally clear by the standards of an honor culture (as witnessed by half
the city refusing to help the fathers), but it is also reasonable for the
fathers to pursue vengeance for the murder of their sons. Many of the
Icelandic sagas explore how to resolve the situation of the murder of a
family member when the killer refuses to pay the murder-price (or the
aggrieved sets it unreasonably high), and the sagas offer commentary on
the results: sometimes ignoring it is positive, sometimes not; sometimes
lying in wait for the other person is seen positively and other times not.
But the Odyssey largely removes the tension, since we see Athena
talking to Zeus about it and Zeus saying that it would be best for
everyone to end up friends. So they have a fight (because there is no
other way to resolve the situation) on the penultimate page, and of course
Odysseus wins, and the situation is resolved. But they were defeated by
force and so they swore friendship, but that does not resolve the
simmering anger underneath? I think the Icelandic sagas would say that
this was not well-resolved.
The tale does introduce a lot of interesting themes, even though it does
not seem to explore them deeply. Odysseus does move from boasting at
outwitting Polyphemos to very humble at the Phaiakians, and even hiding
his identity out of necessity at his homecoming. His hubris with
Polyphemos is partly responsible for his suffering, since he made an enemy
of Poseidon. Although Odysseus is physically strong and one of the
far-famed fighters, he returns home by perseverance and by
craftiness/cunning. There is also the tendency of the non-highborn to
folly, such as his men opening the bag of winds (although arguably they
were under the influence of a god) and eating the cattle of a god to fill
their stomachs rather than respecting other’s property at the expense of
their own hunger (that is, lacking self-control in an important
situation). Odysseus passes up the opportunity for immortality in
preference for love of home (a tension sadly unexplored), once explicitly
with Calypso and once implicitly with Circe. Of course, the theme of
recovering honor as one escaping from Calypso destitute and returning one
man against a small army of armed squatters in your house.
There is a small, but interesting window onto the economy of the time (at
least, as perceived later by the poets). Odysseus is given thirteen
talents of gold by the Phaiakian kings, but unlike the biblical talent of
75 pounds, a talent of this time was about one gold coin, roughly
equivalent to a Roman gold solidus (and since Odysseus hand carries a
chest with the gold and thirteen sets of cloths, the gold was clearly not
very heavy). Values are hard to come by, but around Constantine’s time a
solidus was worth 275,000 denarii. In Jesus’ time the denarius was one
day’s wage for a common person, so if we account for the debasement of the
currency, one gold coin in Rome could be worth somewhere between 38 and
100 years’ wages. However, in the Iliad, a talent of gold seems
equivalent to one ox (roughly $3000 today), so probably much less than in
Roman times, although the value of an ox to us and to the ancient Greeks
without modern farming yields could be different. The fine clothing,
however, was presumably hardly inexpensive, since it was paired with the
gold as a gift. Odysseus also gets thirteen tripods, which in the Iliad
are valued at twelve oxen per tripod, so his story (and perhaps their
sympathy) was worth a lot more than the expected guest-gift. What I find
interesting is that thirteen tripods and cauldrons, thirteen gold coins,
and thirteen sets of fine clothes are said to be more plunder than he
would have had if he had come back from Troy without troubles. Assuming a
cauldron to be equal in value to a tripod (which seems unlikely, since the
value of tripods is mentioned but not cauldrons, or perhaps the cauldron
is included) and a set of fine clothes as one gold coin, this would be
equivalent to 338 gold coins / oxen. An ordinary female household
working-slave was four oxen in the Iliad, and Odysseus paid
twenty oxen for Eurykleia. So the plunder from Troy would be less than $1
million (at $3000/ox), and the approximately 1200 oxen the suitors offered
was about four times the plunder of Troy. (And thus, Odysseus valued his
honor greater than immense riches.)
I found the Iliad to be the most well-crafted book I have ever
read; the story-telling is riveting if you read it aloud, and the poetic
descriptions frequently left me in awe. I think that to begin to
understand the Iliad is to be able to understand what Literature
is abound. Sadly, I found the Odyssey to be ordinary, as neither
the storytelling nor the poetry is particularly outstanding. It is quite
possible that I am missing something, and possibly compared to all the
other works in the Trojan War cycle (many now lost, others were cited in
the introductions but I had never heard of them) it was a clear second
place, but after reading the Iliad I found the Odyssey
disappointing. However, it is an interesting wonder-tale, it adds to the
corpus of Greek mythology, and is one of the very few windows onto Bronze
Age Greece, hidden by mist as it was even when written.
Review: 7
Completely lacks the genius of the Iliad, and the
story is on rails, with Odysseus and Telemachos essentially making no real
decisions.
Book 1:
Odysseus is trapped on Calypso, and his men perished because they ate
Apollo’s cattle. Zeus is thinking about Aigisthos, who married Agamemnon’s
wife, even though the gods sent Hermes to tell him not to, and killed
Agamemnon, and then himself came to a bad end. But the gods pitied
Odysseus, prevented from coming home by Poseidon, who was in Ethiopia
enjoying a hecatomb offered to him. Athena asks Zeus why he hates
Odysseus, and he says I do not, it is Poseidon, but since the rest of us
are all in agreement and he cannot fight against us all united, let him
come home. Athena replied that she would go to his son Telemachos and put
some spirit into him.
She came to Odysseus’ house, and it was Telemachos who saw her, disguised
as Mentes, a guest-friend of Odysseus. He gave her proper hospitality, and
set a meal for her, and told her that he wished his dead father were back
to rid the house of these suitors. Supposedly as Mentes, she said that
Odysseus was not dead but the gods were impeding his return, and asked him
if he were really Odysseus’ son, since he looked like him, and what is
this feast going on? Telemachos replied that no one knows who his father
is, but he was told that he was Odysseus’ son. The feast, he said, the
many suitors for his mother’s hand, who just stay on and are eating up all
his positions. A said situation, replies Athena; if Odysseus were here he
would kill those suitors and show them that marriage is a painful thing!
Do what I tell you: tonight announce to them that you summon an assembly
and that you want them out of here. At the assembly, if they do not agree
to leave, tell them you will not pursue the matter but will ask the gods
for justice. Then take a ship and go to Nestor and Menelaos in Sparta and
see if they have heard anything. Tell the people that if, in a year, you
have heard nothing or find out that Odysseus is dead, you will have your
mother choose a husband. Then, despite Telemachos wanting to give her a
gift, she insists on leaving. His mother Penelope, hearing the song the
singer is singing, comes out to tell them not to sing anything that
reminds her of her husband and Troy, but Telemachos says tells her to go
back in her chambers, recent songs are the most requested and there is
nothing wrong with that. (So she goes back and falls asleep crying.) Then
Telemachos tells the suitors that he is summoning an assembly for tomorrow
about them leaving and not eating up his property. They were surprised at
this new, assertive, Telemachos and Antinoos says he hopes that Telemachos
does not become their king (despite it being his inheritance), to which
Telemachos replies that being a king is not a bad thing, but whether he is
or not, he will be master of his own house.
Book 2:
The assembly convenes and Telemachos says that he wants the suitors to
leave and stop eating up his property. Antinoos says angrily that he is
impetuous, and that they will not leave as long as his mother refuses to
choose a suitor, because she told them four years ago that she would
choose one after she finished weaving a grave cloth for the hero Laertes
so there is something to wrap him in when he dies. But after three years
we found out she was undoing her days’ work at night, and we forced her to
finish it. So until she stops putting us off, or you tell her to go back
to her father (who will choose a suitor and give a large gift, as is
appropriate for a bride) we are staying. Telemachos says he cannot throw
his own mother out of his house, so he will ask Zeus to reverse their
fortunes and kill them with no payment given. Zeus sent two eagles, which
swooped over them, fought a bit, then left on the right. An old man, said
that this is an ill omen for the suitors—and you all know that I have a
history, and you also know I prophesied that Odysseus would come back
after twenty years, which is now. One suitor said, aged sir, sit down, we
think your prophecy is nonsense. Then Telemachos brings his complaint to
the larger body of people, asking why they are not doing anything. Another
of the suitors said that there are many of us, and we are all the
nobility, and even if Odysseus came back he would find an unhappy end
outnumbered, so I think it will be hard to force us to leave. Then
Telemachos asks for a ship, to go to Nestor and Sparta and ask about his
father, and if he finds out he is dead or has not heard anything, he will
tell his mother to pick a husband. A suitor said, go ahead, but I do not
think this will come about, since you have no ships or companions.
He prays to the god that came to him, and Athene, in the form of Mentor,
Odysseus’ friend entrusted with the care of his household, and said that
she would make it happen. So she went and told twenty men to come, and
asked for a ship. She had told Telemachos to prepare provisions, so he
asked the keeper of the stores, an old woman named Eurykleia (who Laertes
had bought for twenty oxen from her father [presumably as a bride], but
loved as a wife, but never slept with because he was afraid that his wife
would be angry), who had nursed Telemachos. She said he should stay safe
here, but he insisted on going and told her to tell no one. So they met on
the beach, and Athena gave them good wind, and they hoisted the sail into
the hole in its box and made it fast with stays.
Book 3:
Telemachos arrives as Nestor is offering a hecatomb to Poseidon. He and
Athena-Mentor are invited to the feast, and Telemachos asks after
Odysseus. Nestor says that after they sacked Troy, Menelaos wanted to
leave immediately and try to escape the anger of Athena, while Agamemnon
wanted to stay and try to appease it. Nestor was among those following
Menelaos, and Nestor’s group got good winds and came home easily. Odysseus
went with them, but came back to Agamemnon. Nestor did not know what
happened to Odysseus, but at Telemachos’ request tells what happened to
Agamemnon: Aigisthos spent a lot of time courting Agamemnon’s wife, who
was not the adulterous sort, but she was worn down by the gods
(apparently). Aigisthos killed Agamemnon, but was killed by Agamemnon’s
son Orestes later. Nestor insists on them sleeping in his house as guests,
but Athena-Mentor says that is good for Telemachos, but he must get back
to the ship, because he is the only one who could be considered an elder
of the men. Then Athena turns into a vulture and flies off, with Nestor
awed at the recognition of Athena [apparently a vulture was related to
her?] and also glad that Odysseus’ patron Athena was come to the aid of
his son. Telemachos sleeps in Nestor’s portico. The next day, Nestor
offers a cow to Athena, and gilds her horns; Telemachos is bathed, and
they feast on shishkabobs. The day after, Nestor sends his son
Peisistratos to drive Telemachos to Lakadaimon (Sparta) to ask Menelaos.
Book 4:
They arrive at a double wedding, of Menelaos’ daughter to one of
Achilles’ sons (fulfilling his promise to Achilles in Troy, only to his
son), and his son to someone else’s daughter. Menelaos invites them in,
and while they eat he wonders if he should ask him if he is Odysseus’ son.
Then Helen comes down and says he much be Odysseus’ son. Peisistratos say
that Telemachos is Odysseus’ son, but too modest to say so. Menelaos then
says how Odysseus was a great friend, and says that, in hindsight, he
wished the war never happened, as the best of the Argives perished and he
no longer had his friend Odysseus, whom he would have given one of his own
cities to rule, so that they could visit each other. Helen relates a story
of how Odysseus flagellated himself and dressed in poor clothing, and was
taken in Troy as a beggar. Only Helen recognized him, but he made her
swear not to tell. Then he killed many and gained much information. [The
text seems to suggest that Helen might have told afterwards, but then
presumably they would have blamed her for letting the killings happen.]
Menelaos relates how Odysseus was unmoved, when the best of the warriors
were in the Trojan Horse, and Helen walked around the horse, calling to
the men in their wives’ voices. Some of the best were on the verge of
replying and dooming them all, and Odysseus wrapped his arms around their
mouths to keep them silent.
Then Menelaos relates what happened to Odysseus. Menelaos had gone all
over, to Egypt, Ethiopia, Lybia and elsewhere, gaining all the treasure
that Telemachos had admired in his house (and which Menelaos said he would
rather have a third of the treasure and his friends back). Well, they had
made it to Pharos, a day’s voyage from Egypt and were trying to get home,
but had poor wind for twenty days and food was scarce. Menelaos met the
daughter of the Old Man of the Sea, and asked her what god was preventing
him from getting home. She said to ask her father the next day: ambush him
when he takes his afternoon nap, hold onto him while he shifts form, and
when he returns to his original form he will tell you what you ask. At
dawn she covered them in freshly killed seal skins in the cave where her
father slept (and gave them some ambrosia to smell, since the seal smell
was overpowering). The Old Man came in, counted the seals as he did, and
went to sleep, and they jumped him, he transformed shape, but tired and
came to himself. Then he told Menelaos that Aigisthos had hired a watchman
for two talents of gold, who alerted him when Agamemnon landed. He was
welcomed home, but at the feast all his men (and Aigisthos’ men) were
killed. Eight years later, Orestes killed Aigisthos, and had a burial
mound raised for his mother [unclear if he killed her, but she did die].
After Menelaos had wept for a while, he inquired after the other one who
had no homecoming, since the Old Man had said that there were only two.
The Old Man said that Odysseus was being held captive by Calysto who
wanted him as a husband, but that Menelaos was being held back because he
had not offered a complete hecatomb to the gods, and he would have to go
back to Egypt and do it right, which he did.
As Telemachos was sailing back, Antinoos, shocked that Telemachos
actually was able to pull off the voyage, said that they need to ambush
him on the way back, so he borrows a ship and twenty of them sail out to a
hidden harbor on a small island just off Ithaca. The herald overheard
this, and told Penelope, who asked why someone did not tell her he was
leaving; she would have prevented it and so prevented the loss of her son.
Eurykleia said that she did know, but that Telemachos made her swear that
she would not tell anyone, unless it had been twelve days or her mother
found out herself. Penelope cries herself to sleep, over her husband of
good character, but mostly over her son. Athena sends her a dream, where
her sister tells her that the gods will see her son safely home.
Book 5:
At Athena’s indirect request, Zeus tells Hermes to tell Calypso to let
Odysseus go and send him on his way. She is upset, since the gods take
whatever mortal woman they want but never let the goddesses have the man
they want: the gods resented Dawn’s choice of Orion and Artemis killed
him, and Zeus killed Demeter’s lover Iasion with a thunderbolt. But who
can resist Zeus? So she went to Odysseus, who every day wept for his home
and his wife by the ocean, but was compelled by Calypso to lie beside her
at night. She told him she would help him leave if he wanted (“although
you will have hardships, and here you would be immortal, and I compare not
unfavorably with mortal women”), and he could build a raft. He said that
this must be more pain she was devising for him, but she swore oaths that
she was helping him. Despite the fact that he wept every day and was weary
of her, somehow that night they “enjoyed each other in love”. So she gave
him tools and he cut down dry trees, planed the logs, fastened them with a
dowel, and made a shelter and a mast and a rudder, and after four days had
finished it. She gave him cloth for it, and also food, water and wine. He
levered the raft down to the water, and sailed, keeping Orion on his left
as Calypso instructed. All went well for seventeen days, and then Poseidon
came back from Ethiopia and saw Odysseus nearing the Paiakians, from where
he was fated to return to Ithaca. So Poseidon stirred up a storm. A sea
nymph saw him and took pity on him (and also gave him the information that
it was Poseidon, not Zeus, who was making his life difficult), and gave
him her veil, which she said was immortal and to tie it around his waist
and swim to land, and then throw it back in the sea (without looking) when
he got to shore. The land had looked far away before the storm came, so
Odysseus stayed on the raft until Poseidon broke it to pieces with a wave.
After Poseidon left, Athena calmed the winds and made the waters smoother,
but Odysseus was three days in the water, and then had to swim around the
island until he found a river, which he supplicated in prayer, for even an
immortal god is expected to help a wanderer and stranger in need, and he
made it to land. Then he went inland to avoid the chills of the sea, and
found a dense copse of trees, and made a bed of leaves and covered himself
with them like someone in a remote area covers the dying fire with ashes
so that it will be alive in the morning, since he cannot relight it.
Book 6:
Athena came in a dream to Nausicaä, daughter of Alkinoös, king of the
Phaicians, that she needed to do her laundry, since she would be getting
married soon. So when she woke up, the girl asked her father for the
ox-cart to do laundry for her bachelor brothers (which it seems she may
have been responsible for), and he said of course and told them men to get
ready the ox-cart. So she riding and her handmaidens walking came to the
washing place by the river, which was a bit far from the city, and they
washed the clothes and stomped on them and made a game of it. Then they
had lunch, and played ball-games. Athena had Nausicaä miss, so the ball
went in the river and the girls shouted in surprise, which woke up
Odysseus. He was worried that they might be more nymphs, but came out
boldly, like a hungry lion even when there are hunter around, and covering
his privates with a tree branch. He addressed Nausicaä as “queen” and
asked if she were a goddess or mortal, and if the latter, that observed
that certainly she was as beautiful as a goddess, and he verbally
supplicated her for hospitality as a wandering stranger. She welcomed him
hospitably, and told her handmaidens to bathe him and gave him olive oil
to anoint himself with. But he asked the handmaidens to leave him because
he was embarrassed to be naked around them, and he bathed and anointed
himself, and dressed in clothes Nausicaä had provided. Afterwards he
looked rather dashing, especially since Athena had arranged his hair curls
just so and had given him an air of grace. He was so handsome
[despite being late middle-aged by now] that Nausicaä wished he could be
her husband, so someone like him. She said he should supplicate her
mother, rather than her father, but said that once they got to the copse
of trees sacred to Athena, he should hide there for a while until he
judged they had made it back home, and then come to the city and ask
directions to her parents’ house and supplicate her mother. Because, she
said, it would be unseemly for her to come back being friendly with a man,
especially since all the best men of city were wooing her and she
apparently not entirely excited about any of them.
Book 7:
Odysseus came to the city, and Athena wrapped him in mist, because
outlanders were sometimes not seen kindly. She appeared as a young girl,
and he asked her the way to Alkinoös’ house, and she took him, since she
said it was close to her own father’s house. At the door frame he paused
to admire the bronze walls with the cobalt blue trimmings, and the large
orchards. Then he went in, unseen by anyone despite the ongoing feast,
since he was still wrapped in mist, and grasped Arete’s knees, the wife of
Alkinoös. He asked them to take him home in their ships, and then sat down
in the ashes in the fireplace. One of the men said to Alkinoös that it is
not right that strangers and guests—sacred to Zeus—should sit in the
fireplace. Alkinoös agreed, and promised to do prepare everything the next
day. Then Alkinoös moved his oldest son from his right hand, and sat
Odysseus there, and gave him food and drink. Afterwards, Arete, noticing
that he was wearing fabric she, herself, and woven, asked where he had
come from and where he had gotten his clothing. Odysseus said he had been
held by Calypso for seven years and released on the eighth, and related
everything told above, including what Nausicaä had done. Alkinoös said
that he was disappointed his daughter did not bring him in herself, but
Odysseus said that it was not because of any fault of hers, but rather he
was too embarrassed to follow behind. Then they made him a bed on the
portico, but Alkinoös went and slept next to his wife.
Book 8:
The next day Alkinoös took Odysseus to the council area with its smooth
stone benches, and Athena went in the guise of his herald and told the
leading men to come and see the god-like stranger. Alkinoös selected 52
men and told them to take a new black ship that had never sailed down to
the water, make her ready, and attach the long oars. This they did, while
everyone else, including the twelve sub-kings on the island went to feast.
They ate and drank their fill, and the bard sang long and well, and
Odysseus drew his purple hood over his head and wept when he heard songs
from the Trojan War. But only Alkinoös, sitting next to him noticed, and
he said that there had been enough song, it was time for athletic games,
to show the stranger how they excel in athletics. There was a foot-race,
discus-throwing, wrestling, boxing, and the king’s sons won several of
these. Then one king’s eldest asked Odysseus to compete, since from his
build he looked to be no stranger to athletics, but Odysseus said he just
wanted to go home. Then Euryalos, who had won wrestling, said to Odysseus
that clearly he was no athlete, but rather a merchant eager for profit.
This angered Odysseus, so said that it was a word poorly spoken and gave
words of instruction on the topic. Then he grabbed a heavier discus than
they had been using, and threw it farther than all the others (so far that
a blind man could feel that there were no others around it). He said he
was used to doing well, and said he would accept a competition between any
of them in any of the games (except Alkinoös’ oldest son, because it is
not seemly to fight one’s friend and host), except that he might lose a
foot race since the raft did not offer any way to keep up his conditioning
for his feet. There was silence, and Alkinoös said that they should move
on to dancing, and show the stranger how unsurpassed the Phaiakians were
at dancing. They brought back the bard, and he played his lyre and sang
about how Hephaistos caught Ares and (his wife) Aphrodite in the act and
extracted the adultery-price from Ares (guaranteed by Poseidon). They
danced magnificently, and Odysseus was awed. After the dances were
finished, he told Alkinoös that Alkinoös had spoken truly that they were
the best dancers, and Alkinoös was pleased. He declared the stranger a
friend, as a suppliant is supposed to be, and told the twelve kings to
give him each a gift of a well-washed robe, a tunic, and a talent of gold.
They had another feast, and Alkinoös gave him a beautiful golden goblet so
that Odysseus would remember them when he poured libations to the gods,
and had Arete give him a fine chest to put everything in, and a washed
robe and a tunic, and to heat the cauldron for a bath. Odysseus was
excited about the hot bath, since he had not had one in twenty days
(although before then Calypso treated him like a god), and he bathed and
was anointed in oil, and then dressed. Arete brought him the chest, they
put the gifts in, and Alkinoös told Odysseus to seal it with a knot, so he
closed it and tied a knot that Circe had taught him. Then they feasted,
and Odysseus complimented Demodokus, the blind bard, gave him most of his
portion of meat, and said that he would sing his praises abroad if he
would sing about the Trojan Horse. This he did, and told it as accurately
as if he had been there. Odysseus could not stop weeping (as a woman
weeps over the body of her husband who was killed unsuccessfully defending
the city and his family, before she is pushed by the butt of a spear, to
go a life of slavery and work). Alkinoös again was the only one who
noticed, and so he asked Odysseus who he was, and why he wept so much.
Book 9:
Although I would rather not relive my miseries, but since you ask me, I
am wide-famed Odysseus, and we men sailed from Troy and sacked the city of
the Kikonians and shared out their wives and possessions. I said we should
leave quickly, but the men did not want to, which was not good advice,
since their neighbors came early in the morning. Although we were doing
well in the morning, in the afternoon they defeated us and we fled in our
strong-benched ships. We landed in the land of the Lotus Eaters. They were
friendly, and gave the three men I sent to scout lotus flowers to eat, but
this made them forget about going home and want to stay there and eat
lotus flowers. I himself had to go drag them back and tie them up
underneath the benches. Then we landed on the island of the Cyclops, on a
nice beach a ways from where they lived, and we killed a bunch of the
goats and ate without limit. The men thought we should leave, but I took
twelve men to see if the people of the island were godly and honored
strangers and would give me a guest-present. We found a cave of one, which
had ewes and much goat milk and goat cheese, but the man was out. We
helped ourselves to the cheese, but when he came back, placed an enormous
boulder in front of the door, and had milked his goats in order, he asked
us who we were. I said we were followers of Agamemnon returning from Troy,
and invoked hospitality. He said we were fools and he did not care about
Zeus. Then he slapped two of my men to the ground and ate them. I
contemplated stabbing him in the liver with my sword, but did not, since
we could not move the boulder. In the morning he ate another two men, then
led out his sheep. I pondered what to do. In the evening, after he ate
another two men, I gave him some very strong wine that I had taken with
me, just in case, which he eagerly drank and then fell asleep. My men and
I had sharpened a tree he had drying in the cave, and we heated it in the
fire, and myself and four others rammed it into his eye and twisted. He
had asked me my name, to which I said “Nobody”, and when we rammed his eye
he started hollering, and the other Cyclopses came outside and asked why
he had disturbed their sleep. He said that Nobody was hurting him, and
they said, well, in that case they would go back to sleep. Then I tied
sheep together in groups of three and put a man under the middle sheep.
Then I grabbed the underbelly of a rather large ram. In the morning, he
felt the backs of the sheep, but not underneath. He was surprised that the
ram, who normally ran first to get the best grass, was last, and wished he
could talk. We quietly ran to the ship and launched it, and when we were a
shout’s distance out, I taunted him saying that we were escaping. He
grabbed a top of the mountain and threw it at us, narrowing missing the
steering oar and the wave sent us back to the beach. After we had rowed
out I waited until twice the distance, and even though the men tried to
stop me, I taunted him again, saying that he should know that Odysseus of
Ithaca had overcome him. Then he said that the prophecy that he had been
told had been fulfilled, and he prayed to Poseidon that he would kill us
all, or if it was ordained to that I should come home, that I should do so
with the loss of everything, all my companions, in another’s ships, to a
troubled house. Then he threw an even larger stone and narrowly missed our
steering oar, sending us back to the beach where the others were relieved
to see us. We shared the sheep among the boats, and I sacrificed the ram
to Zeus, but he did not receive it.
Book 10:
Next we came to the island of Aiolos, who had six sons and six daughters,
and married them to each other, and they lived, richly provided for in his
palace. He feasted me and gave me gifts, and when I asked him to send us
home, he gave us a bag with all the winds tied up except the West Wind,
since the gods had made him keeper of the winds. I did not let the men
touch the sails, but when we came in sight of Ithaca, sweet sleep overcame
me. While I was sleeping, the men were jealous that I got given a bag full
of treasure, while they, who had done as much as I had, got nothing. So
they opened the bag, and then all the other winds sprang out, and a storm
blew up, and we were blown back to Aiolos. They were surprised to see me
arrive, and when I told what had happened, Aiolos threw me out and said he
would not help someone the cursed by the gods. Then we rowed on and came
to Lamos. I sent some men to investigate, but the inhabitants were giants
and threw man-sized rocks at us and sunk all the ships in the harbor.
However, I had tied my ship to one of the cliffs that surround the harbor,
right at the entrance, so my ship made it out, but all the other men
perished. Sorrowing we rowed on, and came to the island of Aiaia. I
divided the men into two groups of twelve, and the lot fell to the one led
by Eurylochos. They found a lovely house and heard a woman singing while
she worked her loom, Circe, goddess of the lovely hair. They announced
themselves and she graciously invited them in, but Eurlyochos stayed
outside, suspecting treachery. She gave them wine mixed with a potion, and
when they had gratefully drunk it, she turned them into pigs with her wand
and sent them into the pig stye. Eurylochos came back and told me, and so
I went alone to her house. Hermes met me as I neared it, and said I would
not succeed without his help. He gave me a root which would prevent her
potion from working and advised me what to do. So I went to the house, and
she invited me in. I drank her wine, but when she was surprised that her
magic with the wand did not work, I drew my sword and went after her as if
to kill her, as Hermes had advised. As he said she would, she conciliatory
and invited me to sleep with her so that in love we might have faith and
trust in each other. I said that I could not trust her not to unman me in
such a vulnerable state, so she swore an oath that she would not do
anything to me. So I went into her beautiful bed. Afterwards her handmaids
set out a lovely dinner, but she asked why I did not eat. I said I could
not eat while my companions were pigs, so she went and transformed them
back into men (but they were a little younger than before), and we
embraced and lamented. After a while she told us to still our lamenting
and partake of the food. Then she invited all of us to stay, so we went
back to the ships to get them. Eurylochos was unwilling to go, so I said
he could stay there, but he followed us anyway. Circe said since we were
all so tired from Troy and our adventures and losses, that we should stay
until our spirits had returned to the brightness that they were when we
left Ithaca. A year passed, and the men asked me about leaving. So that
night I ascended Circe’s beautiful bed and asked her to keep her promise
to send us off. She said she would not keep us if we were not willing, but
that we needed to go to the land of the dead to ask advice of the prophet
Teiresias (whom Persephone had granted to keep his spirit) how to get
back. The men were disheartened when I told them. Also, the young man
Elpenor died falling of the roof, where he was sleeping drunkenly, when he
heard us leaving and woke up, not realizing where he was. When we got to
the ships, we found that Circe had come and given us two sheep for the
sacrifice to the dead. We had not seen her; who can see an immortal if
they wish it otherwise?
- Odysseus notes that both Calypso (yesterday) and Circe both wanted him
as a husband. He also describes both of them negatively, Circe being
“the dread goddess” and sister of malignant Aietes (Book 10, 136-7).
Calypso, likewise is a “dread goddess” who “loved me excessively” (Book
7, 255-6). Circe tried to keep him by making him forget who he was,
while Calypso kept him by force, but treated him really well and wanted
to make him immortal. He says explicitly that Calypso could not win his
heart. Hermes tells Odysseus not to refuse Circe, since he wants her to
set his companions free.
- Circe is explicitly shown weaving. Presumably Calypso does, too, since
he has “immortal cloth” to give Odysseus.
Book 11:
Odysseus sailed south to the end of the Ocean, where the land is covered
in night. They walked to the place Circe had told them, and then Odysseus
made sacrifices to the dead and promised them a heifer upon his return. He
dug two pits, and filled them with water, wine, and the blood of the two
sheep, and covered them with white barley [which seems to be a part of
sacrifices]. The dead came up, but, as directed, he held out his sharp
sword and prevented them from drinking the blood until Teiresias, the
Athenian prophet, came. He drank, and then prophesied that Odysseus would
need to go back to Circe’s isle, and afterwards would encounter hardships.
He could have a homecoming, but if they ate of Helios’ cattle they would
be destroyed, and if only he refrained, he would come home in hardship,
his house in trouble. Then he left, and Odysseus waited until his mother,
whom he had seen earlier, came back, and after she drank he asked her why
she died. She said that she died out of sorrow for him, but that his
father was still alive, living by himself in his orchard. Then Odysseus
let the women that Persephone sent come up one by one, questioning each.
They were heroic women, who had slept with a god and borne children
(because sleeping with a god always produces results), and they each
briefly told their story. Odysseus stopped and said that he should sleep,
but Alkinoös instructed all the kings to bring him a gift. Then he said
that the night was long, and in any case, he would be happy to listen
until dawn since the story was told so well, and asked if Odysseus had
talked with any of his companions from the war. Odysseus said that he did
not mind the telling if they wanted to hear it. He said that he did talk
with them. Agamemnon came, and Odysseus was surprised and asked whether he
died at sea or in battle. He said none, but that Aigisthos slaughtered him
and his men at a feast in his house, like slaughtering animals for a
feast, ignominiously. In fact his <unkind-word> wife did not even
close his eyes and mouth. He warned Odysseus not to trust women, not even
your wife, but that Penelope has great character and is keeping the
household together [the wife’s job] as best she can, beset with troubles.
He saw Achilles and told him that his glory was well-known. Achilles
replied and said that being a poor thrall in the field is better than
being dead with glory, and asked about his son. He went away pleased when
Odysseus told him that he never slackened from the battle and won himself
with glory at Troy. He talked with others, and it seemed like the heroes
were not shades who had to drink the blood (although this is not entirely
clear), but when the masses of dead started coming, he became green with
fear and went back to the ship.
Book 12:
They went back to Circe’s isle and buried Elpenor, as his shade had
requested in Hades. Then Circle gave them food and they feasted. During
the night she instructed Odysseus on the trials awaiting him, and how to
deal with them. She instructed him not to eat the cattle of Helios, the
same way the ghost of Teiresias had. When Dawn came, with her rosy
fingers, they sailed away. First they came to the Siren’s island, and
Odysseus told them the danger, put softened beeswax in their ears, and
instructed them to lash him to the mast so that he could hear their song.
They sang that they could tell him all about himself and the war, for they
knew everything, and he wanted to hear them, but the men lashed him
tighter, as instructed, and rowed on. He instructed them to keep clear of
the dashing rocks. Then they came to Skylla, who had six head on long
necks, and on the other side, Charybdis who sat under a fig tree and
alternately sucked down the water so you could see the bottom, or spit it
up so that it boiled. Odysseus took two spears to try to fight Skylla,
even though Circe said it was not possible, she was immortal, but they
were so focused on avoiding Charybdis that he did not see Skylla until she
had taken six of their best men into the air, and she ate them in front of
her lair as they screamed. After that they came to the island with Helios’
cattle and sheep. Odysseus wanted to pass it by, but the men were
unanimous in wanted to sleep there, and since they had essentially forced
him, he agreed. He told them not to eat any of the cattle or sheep, but
only the provisions Circe had given. But then there was a storm for seven
days, and unfavorable winds for a month, and they ran out of food. He went
up the island to pray to the gods, but they gave him sleep, and his men
killed some cattle while he was away. Then Odysseus saw what the gods
wanted to do. They did this for several days, but finally the winds were
favorable. However, Helios had sent a messenger to Zeus asking for
recompense for his cattle or he would shine on Hades instead of the earth,
and when the sheep was surrounded by water, he sent a small storm and
smashed the ship with a thunderbolt. The men all died, but Odysseus found
the rudder and another piece, which he lashed together as a makeshift
raft. He was blown all the way back to Charybdis, who was sucking down
water. He clung to a branch of the fig tree that was over the water, until
about dinner time she started spitting the water back up, and he dropped
when he saw his raft and swam to it. Fortunately Skylla did not see him or
was not paying attention or he would not have survived. Eventually he
drifted to Calypso’s island, and that tale, he said, there is no need to
tell, since I hate telling a story again after it has been well-told once.
Book 13:
They all sat spell-bound after he finished his story, then Alkinoös said
they should each give him a tripod and beautifully wrought cauldron. They
feasted again, and at sundown Odysseus asked to be taken back. So they
stowed all his gifts in the ships, and set Odysseus a bed, and he slept
while soundly while they rowed their well-built ship. They came to a beach
on Ithaca, known for its cave sacred to the nymphs. Still sleeping, they
carried his bed onto the beach and piled his gifts around him, and then
left. Now Poseidon, angry that they had taken Odysseus home, went to Zeus
and asked to express his anger by stunning the ship, and prevent their
continuing to convey all men by hiding their city under a mountain. Zeus
said it would be best to turn the ship into stone in sight of the people
on shore, but not to hide their city under a mountain. So he did this, and
the people were confused at what happened, until Alkinoös said that his
father’s prophecy was now completed, that one day after conveying someone
the ship would be stopped and the city hidden under a mountain. So they
resolved to convey no more passengers, and made sacrifice to Poseidon.
When Odysseus woke up, Athena came to him as a boy shepherd, and hid the
shape of Ithaca from Odysseus. He saw a strange land and was upset at the
Phaiakians. He asked the boy where he was, and the boy said he must be
either ignorant for from far off, since this was none other than
well-known Ithaca. He replied that he was from Crete, and had heard of
Ithaca. He had killed the son of Idomeneus on a dark night, for denying
him his share in the plunder of Troy, and had then fled on a Phoenician
ship, but they had slept the night here and left him while he was
sleeping. Athena revealed herself, saying that there was no one like him
for craftiness, except among the gods, herself, then noted that she had
made the Phaiakians love him, and had brought him to the city herself. He
thanked her for all her kindness in the days before his troubled return,
but said he did not think this was Ithaca and that she was devising more
trouble. Athena replied that this kind of thinking was why should could
not abandon him: he reasons closely and does not lose his head—any other
man would have run off after his wife and children. She said that they she
did not think it wise to cross Poseidon, who was angry at him for blinding
his son. Then she told him the situation of his house and he thanked her
for saving him from a fate like Agamemnon’s, and asked her what to do. She
said not to go home, but to go to the swineherd caring for his pigs, and
she changed him into an old man, and gave him lousy clothes to wear. Then
she said she needed to go get his son, who had gone off to Sparta to ask
after him. He asked she had done that, when he was on the verge of coming
home, and she said that she had sent him off so that he could win glory,
and, not to worry, she was going to ensure he came back safely.
Book 14:
Odysseus went and found Eumaios, the swineherd, who received him
graciously in fear of Zeus, killing two small pigs (all that he was
allowed) and roasting the cubed meat. He talked freely about his
frustrations with the suitors eating up Odysseus’ property and having to
send the best pig every day, since Odysseus had been a loving master and
he wished he would come home, though he was sure that he had perished
somewhere on the water. Odysseus was encouraged by his hospitality and his
concern for Odysseus’ property, and tried to reassure him that Odysseus
was coming back, but he said that any wanderer is likely to say that.
Odysseus asked for better clothes (a wanderer’s right, apparently), and
Eumaios said that he would have to wait until Telemachos came back,
because they had no extras. Odysseus then said to wait on the clothes
until Odysseus came back, as he said, and if he did not come back then not
to give them, since he hated liars who said anything their hosts wanted to
hear. Eumaios was not persuaded, but asked Odysseus who he was. He said he
was the son of a concubine of a rich man on Crete. His brothers gave him
little inheritance when his father died, but he gained renown fighting.
After Troy, he spent a month with his wife and kids, but then went off to
Egypt. When they came to the delta, he told his men to stay by the ships
and went into the city, but they plundered the area, killed the men, and
took the women, and then the men of the city came out and attacked them.
He clasped the knees of the king, who protected him, and he stayed in
Egypt seven years and acquired much wealth. But on the eighth he was
deceived by a Phoenician, and spent a year with him, who then sailed to
sell him as a slave at a great price. He had an inkling of this, and
escaped when they spent the night at Ithaca. However, they had previously
spent the night at a king’s house along the way, where he heard that
Odysseus was coming back. Eumaios still did not believe it. When the four
swineherds he was in charge of came back, he killed the fattest pig,
wrapped the appropriate parts with fat and put it on the fire as a
sacrifice, and roasted the meat. That night, Odysseus tested Eumaios to
see if he would be courteous and give him his cloak for the cold, telling
a story about how he was with Odysseus at Troy, and had forgotten his
cloak and was freezing, and Odysseus got one of the guy to run back to
give Agamemnon a message, which allowed him to sleep in that man’s cloak.
Eumaios said that the story was well-spoken and to the point, and got up
and gave him warm sheepskins.
Book 15:
Athena came to Telemachos in the night and told him that it no longer
became him to stay at Menelaos’ house, but he should get back to his own,
in case his mother married, because women pay no attention to former
children and their former husband once they have remarried. He should set
one of the trustworthy of the women-servants over it until the gods showed
him who was his wife. And he should be aware that the suitors were trying
to kill him, and to go to the swineherd once he arrived, instead of back
home. So he told Menelaos that he needed to leave, which disappointed him,
and he offered to take him on a tour of mainland kings (“each of whom will
give us a tripod and a cauldron, or something equally nice”), but
Telemachos said he must go. So Menelaos speachified on how one should
neither be too friendly and not let a guest leave, nor unfriendly and not
welcome a guest, and then gave him a silver mixing bowl and some other
things, and Helen gave him the loveliest robe that she had woven, for his
wife to wear at their wedding. He and Nestor’s son went back, and on the
second day, Telemachos asked him to take him directly to his ship.
Nestor’s son thought that this was best, since his father would surely
force him to stay, but said he should sail immediately, because even so he
was likely to come down and make it impossible to leave. So Telemachos had
his men prepare to leave, and while he was pouring libations and praying,
Theoklymenos, a prophet and one who was an exile due to having killed
someone, begged him to take him aboard, to which Telemachos says that of
course he would. They sailed without incident around the islands instead
of going the short way, and came to the harbor of Ithaca. Theoklymenos
asked him where he should go, and Telemachos said that ordinarily he would
invite him to his high-roofed house, but because of the violent suitors he
said that would not be a good plan, and asked one of his men to host him,
and the guest said that it would be no problem. As they disembarked, a
bird flew on their right, and Theoklymenos said that it boded well.
- Interesting that Athena needs to use a wand, too, like Circe, despite
being a high goddess.
Book 16:
Odysseus saw the dogs fawning and not barking, and told Eumaios that
someone they knew must be here. He met Telemachos, who promised him a
tunic and clothing. Eumaios rejoiced at seeing Telemachos, whom he had
assumed would not come back from his voyage. Odysseus asked Telemachos how
it was that his possessions were being eaten up, if maybe he had fallen
out of favor with the people, and said that if he were only younger he
would help, but wished that Odysseus would return because the situation
was outrageous. Telemachos said that his line was always just a single
male, so he had no brothers to help him, and the suitors were very
numerous (about one hundred, from Ithaca and the neighboring islands), and
moreover the best men of Ithaca were among them. Then he sent Eumaios to
Penelope to tell him that he had returned. Athena came, and Telemachos was
turned away from her, but the dogs saw her tall figure and whimpered, and
to Odysseus she said that he should reveal himself. She tapped him with
her wand and restored him to strong middle-age. When Telemachos turned
back, he saw that Odysseus was no longer aged, but was strong and handsome
like a god, and he told Odysseus that he must be a god, and not to harm
him, but he would bring sacrifice. Odysseus said that he was surely not
one of the immortals, but Telemachos’ father, returned. Telemachos did not
believe him, but Odysseus said that Athena was with him, and changed his
form from strong to aged and back, because she is able to do that sort of
thing. Telemachos rejoiced. Then Odysseus asked how many suitors there
were, and whether two of the would be enough or if they needed help.
Telemachos said that they were many and, while he would follow his father,
two people would likely lead to disaster. Odysseus asked if two helpers,
Athena and Zeus would be sufficient, seeing as how Athena was planning all
this, and he did admit that this was likely enough. Now the suitors
discovered that their ambush had failed—the ambushing ship complaining
that they had kept a sharp lookout day and night and did not even see him.
Antinoös said that he thought Telemachos would turn the people’s opinion
against them and would not let them leave, so they needed to find him
outside the city and kill him. Amphinomos, the leader from Duchilion, and
whose talk pleased Penelope the most (since he had “good sense and
discretion”), said that he would not kill a king’s son, since the gods are
not pleased with this, so he thought they should ask the gods first, and
give up the idea if they refuse. At the feast that night, Penelope made
one of her rare appearances and upbraided Antiloös and the suitors for
lying in wait to kill her son, and to stop trying to kill him. Eurylachos,
who had offered the most gifts and was the one Penelope’s parents were
pressing her to marry, said that he remembered Odysseus putting him on his
knees, and he said that I will say this and it will be a thing
accomplished: I will spear the man who tries to kill Telemachos, so have
no fear, but if the gods ordain it what can we do. But as he said this, he
was plotting how to do exactly that.
Book 17:
Telemachos told Eumaios to take the stranger into the city so he could
beg, and then left to show himself to his mother, Penelope, who cried when
she saw him, and kissed his forehead and both eyes (as Eumaios did when he
saw him). She thought she would never see him again. Then Telemachos went
to get his guest, and they ate and put away their hunger. Theoklymenos
told Penelope that the bird he saw presaged Odysseus’ return home, to
which she said that she wished it would come to pass, and if so, she would
give him gifts. Eumaios took Odysseus to the city, where, at the well in
the center, Odysseus’ goatherd insulted him and said that he should be
killed. Odysseus called upon the nymphs that the well was dedicated to to
hear him and bring vengeance. When they came to Odysseus’ house, he told
Eumaios that this must be the place, since it is so large and grand and it
seemed that there was much feasting, and Eumaios told him that he was
right. In the forecourt there was an old, dying dog sitting on a dung
heap, whom Odysseus had raised, right before he left, and it recognized
his voice and wagged its tail, but was too weak to get up. Odysseus asked
Eumaios about the dog, and received the reply that once it was a fine dog,
before Odysseus left and the servants neglected their duties, for when a
man becomes a slave the gods take half his virtue. Odysseus said it might
not be wise for both to come in together, so Eumaios went first and sat
down by Telemachos, and then Odysseus went later and Telemachos invited
him to join them and gave them food. After everyone had put away their
desire to eat and drink, Odysseus went begging to each of the suitors.
Everyone gave him something, except Antinoös, who refused, even after
Telemachos pointed out that he was giving other people’s food, not his
own, which demonstrated he thought only of himself. This angered Antinoös,
who noted that he had a long supply of food without him, and threw a
footstool at Odysseus, hitting him in the back below the right shoulder,
but Odysseus did not flinch. Telemachos seethed at this insult to a
stranger in his house but kept it within him. Penelope, when she heard of
it, said a prayer that the deed be punished. Even the other suitors said
that this was not well done, since often the gods come as strangers, but
Antinoös took no notice. Penelope, hearing that the stranger had news of
Odysseus asked for him to come to her, but Odysseus said that it was less
risky after sundown, when the suitors had gone home and they could speak
privately. Penelope observed that this was reasonable and wise.
Book 18:
There was a large and fat beggar, nicknamed Iros because he would run on
messages, who begged from the suitors. They egged him on to fight the old
stranger and drive him off, promising a large pasty of blood and fat to
the winner. Iros was all eager until Odysseus said that, old as he was,
the need of his future hunger pushed him to fight so that he could keep
his seat at the threshold, and pushing back his rags revealed strong
limbs. The suitors egged him on until it was impossible that he back out,
and Odysseus hit him softly, below the ear, laying him out on the floor,
bleeding, but did not kill him. The suitors laughed and cheered his
victory. Taking his food-prize from Amphinomos, he said that it is wise to
realize that the gods give change of fortunes, and although you are young
and courageous now, his experience is that the gods can ruin you, and here
are these insulting suitors, and Odysseus on his way, and he hoped that
Amphinomos would not be there when he returned. Amphinomos said down,
thoughtful, but could not see a way out, because Athena was determined
that he should die. Penelope, whom Athena had given the idea, and had put
to sleep while she made her more beautiful, came down and upbraided
Telemachos that beggar guests should fight in his hall. He said that it
was not their idea. Then Penelope told the suitors, who were all lusting
after her, addressing Eurymachos, that Odysseus when he left had told her
that the Trojans were reputed to be good warriors and that he might not
return, but if he did not, keep the household until Telemachos grew a
beard and then marry whomever she wished, which was now coming to
pass—but normally suitors brought the victims for the feast and gifts,
rather than eating up the property of the sought-after. Antinoös said that
they were staying until she made her choice, but that whoever wanted to
bring a gift was free to. So they all gave her a lovely gift, beautifully
made clothes and lovely necklaces, leaving Odysseus pleased at how she
managed to wrangle gifts out of them. Then the suitors wanted to sing and
dance, so they had the handmaidens set up three light-fires. Odysseus told
them to go, and he would tend the fires, even all night if necessary,
since he was long-enduring. One of the handmaids, who was sleeping with
Eurymachos, said that either the wine or his victory over Iros had gone to
his head, but he called her a bitch and said he would go to Telemachos who
would punish them, and they left hastily, afraid. Eurymachos challenged
beggar-Odysseus to work for a living on his property, instead of taking
the lazier way and begging food. Odysseus replied that he wished it were
spring, so they could compete at cutting grass with the sickle, or plowing
furrows, or working cattle, and he would find his endurance no easy thing
to keep up with. Eurymachos, angered, replied that either the wine or his
victory over the other beggar must have gone to his head, and threw a
footstool at him, but Odysseus crouched down and it hit the cupbearer.
Then the other suited complained that now this beggar had ruined their
feast with his insolence, and Telemachos said that some god obviously had
disturbed their customary good behavior, and that since they had feasted,
they should go home, but only when they were ready, for he would not drive
out any man. The suitors were surprised at this boldness, and Amphinomos
said that this was spoken orderly, and they should retire. So after they
had poured out libations and had a round of drinks they left.
Book 19:
The housemaid sleeping with Eurymachos scolded Odysseus for still being
here, telling him not to wear out his welcome, to which Odysseus gave her
a speech warning her not to assume that her present fortune would last, as
he is an example that it may not. Penelope also replied, telling the maid
that she knew the “monstrous thing” she was doing and noted that she was
there when she agreed to talk with the stranger privately at night. Penelope had her chair brought down and one for the stranger, with fleeces
to sit on. She asked him where he came from and who he was, but Odysseus
declined to answer, saying that it stir sorrow and that excessive weeping
is improper for a guest. She, responding to his polite comment on her
beauty said that she lost her beauty when Odysseus went to cursed,
not-to-be-named Ilion (Troy), then told about the suitors and her current
situation, and again asked Odysseus about himself. Odysseus said he was
from a wealthy family in Crete, and had feasted Odysseus and his men in
his house as they were going to Troy, having been blown off-course. She
said that he needed to describe what Odysseus was wearing to validate his
claim. Odysseus protests that it has been nineteen years and he will have
to go from memory, and then proceeds to describe in exact detail what
Odysseus was wearing nineteen years ago, down to the carving on his
brooch. Crying, she said that she had woven this exact garment and had put
the brooch on it herself. Odysseus told her to stop mourning, that the
king of the Thespotians, where he had been allegedly wandering, had told
him that Odysseus’ ship was destroyed by Zeus because his men ate Helios’
cattle, but that Odysseus had been brought back by the Phaiakians, and was
even now coming home. She said that if what he said was true she would
shower him with gifts, but did not expect to give any. But she said that
she would give him clothes, and a bath and a bed for the night and he
should stay at her house. Odysseus thanked her, but said he that good
clothes have been hateful to him since he left Crete, that he slept for so
long on the ground that he preferred the ground over a bed, and that he
was too bashful to have any woman bathe him, except for an old woman, that
he would accept. Penelope said that he was the most honorable guest, and
got Eurykleia to bathe him. She noticed his scar he got while killing a
boar on a hunt at his grandfather’s house and she recognized him. She
tried to signal Penelope, but Odysseus asked her why she was trying to
kill him by revealing his secret, told her to keep the secret, and said if
she told any one, it would be a thing accomplished that he would kill her
along with all the unfaithful housemaids (despite her being his nurse as a
baby). She said that she had always had discretion, and went off to get
more water, because she had spilled everything in her surprise. Penelope
asked him to interpret a dream where an eagle killed the twenty geese in
her house, and Odysseus said that it obviously meant that Odysseus was
coming back and would kill the suitors, since in the dream the eagle
turned into Odysseus and explicitly said so. Penelope said she though that
this dream came from the ivory gate of untrue dreams instead of the
polished horn gate of true dreams, and said that she would be married
soon, since she was going to have the suitors shoot an arrow through the
holes in axes, and pick the one who did best. Odysseus told her not to put
off the trial of the arrows through the axes, for Odysseus would surely
come before any of them could handle the bow of Odysseus. Penelope went
upstairs to bed and cried herself to sleep, as usual.
Book 20
He had trouble sleeping, since he was trying to figure out how he could
kill the suitors all by himself, but Athena came and told him to sleep
peacefully, because she was helping him and even if an army attacked him,
they would be slaughtered. But Penelope prayed to Artemis that she would
strike her dead with her arrows. In the morning Eumaios the swineherd came
with some fattened porkers. The goatherd also came with the goats for the
day and insulted Odysseus and said that they would have to exchange fists
since he was begging overmuch and did not work, but Odysseus ignored him.
Philoitios came with an ox and goats, and Odysseus learned that he was
staying instead of escaping elsewhere because he was hoping Odysseus would
come back and give the suitors what-for. Odysseus asked Zeus for an omen,
if he was really planning to help him, and it thundered out of the clear
sky, and the weakest of the mill-women, who was still grinding grain,
announced that it was an omen and expressed desire for Odysseus to kill
suitors (whose large feasts required the mill-women to grind lots of
grain). Telemachos seated Odysseus at a poor table with food, and
announced that no one should insult him or they might get in a fight.
Athena stirred up Ctessipos from Same, who mocked Odysseus and threw and
ox-hoof at him, but Odysseus ducked and it hit the wall. Telemachos said
that it was good that it missed, because anyone who hit a guest in my hall
would get my spear-point through his heart, and then there would be a
funeral instead of marriage for him. One of the suitors said that this was
properly spoken, and told them not to hit strangers in the hall, but then
gave gentle advice to Telemachos that he should be supportive of his
mother marrying, so that he could have his house to himself. Telemachos
said that he was supportive, but would not insist that his mother leave
(and by implication, marrying). Athena stirred the suitors to excessive
laughter. Theoklymenos upbraided the suitors, and prophesied Odysseus’
return. They mocked him and told him to get out, and he went back to the
house of Peiraios, where Telemachos sent him on arrival. Then the suitors
mocked Telemachos, saying he had bad luck with guests: a vagabond who will
not work and a bum who prophesies, and that it would be better to put them
on a ship to Sicily and get a good price for them as slaves. And Penelope
said in her chair in a doorway and overheard everything being said.
Book 21
The next day Penelope brought down the great bow of Odysseus, his arrows,
and twelve axes and announced the contest to the suitors. To the amazement
of the suitors, Telemachos dug a trench in the floor and set up the axes
in a straight line using a string, without having seen it before.
Telemachos tried the bow first, and would have strung it on the fourth
try, but Odysseus signaled to him not to, so he lamented his lack of
strength. Then the suitors tried it out in order from how the wine was
served, all failing. Meanwhile, Odysseus talked to Eumaios and the oxherd
outside and found that they were willing to fight for Odysseus. He said
that he was, indeed Odysseus, and showed them the scar on his knee from
the boar, and he promised to find them wives and consider them companions
of Telemachos. They rejoiced at his return (cried and lamented, actually),
until Odysseus said that it was enough, we need to be quiet. Then he gave
them Philoitios to bar the does of the hall on the outside, and for
Eumaios to bring the bow when he asked for it. Then they went inside. When
all the suitors had tried and failed, Odysseus asked to try. Antinoös was
angry with him, but Penelope said to let him try, since he surely would
not take her away, and if he was able to do it she would give him clothes,
sandals, and a spear, so he could go wherever he wished. Antinoös said
that he was not worried about that, but everyone would be very embarrassed
if they, the finest men of Ithaca could not string the bow while a
vagabond succeeded. Then Telemachos told Penelope to go back to her room,
since he was the authority in the house, the bow was his, even to give
away if he wished. Eumaios brought the bow to Odysseus, not without threat
from Antinoös, which Telemachos defused at his own expense, then he told
Eurykleia to bar the doors, and Philoitios wrapped the rope around them
from the outside and returned. Odysseus examined the bow very carefully to
see if it had been damaged by rot while he was away, causing comment from
the suitors, and then easily strung the bow and sent an arrow through the
hole in all the twelve axeheads. Then he signaled to Telemachos, who came
over to him wearing bronze armor.
Book 22:
Then Odysseus shot Antinoös in the neck as he was about to drink wine
from the golden two-handed goblet. Eurymachos yelled at him, and Odysseus
replied, you dogs did not think I would return from Troy, and you ate up
my household, slept with my housemaids, and wooed my wife while I was
still alive. Then they turned weak from green fear, except Eurymachos who
said that he was right to be angry, but that Antinoös was the leader, and
since he now perished of his folly, they would each pay him back 12 oxen.
Odysseus said that he would not accept everything he and his father owed.
So Eurymachos drew his sword, but was immediately shot under the right
nipple. Telemachos said he would go and get weapons and armor for them, to
which Odysseus said, do it before I run out of arrows. Each of the arrows
found its mark, and Telemachos returned and they armored up. But the
goatherd went through a ventilation opening and got weapons and armor from
the storeroom for the suitors (Telemachos had not properly shut it in his
haste) and started passing them to the suitors. So, on Odysseus’
instructions Eumaios and Philoitios went to the storeroom, hid, and
surprised him. They strung him with his legs and knees behind him on a
rope. Then they came back. The suitors with weapons threw their spears at
the four, but Athena caused them to miss wildly. The four returned volley
and killed four. Then the suitors tried again, with the same results, and
the four killed another four. They they laid to with the sword. At the
end, one of the suitors, who had not approved of their behavior and who
was a diviner, clasped Odysseus’ knees and asked for pardon, since he was
a diviner and had done nothing. Odysseus said that he must have prayed
against his return, and beheaded him. Then the singer of songs clasped his
knees and said that he was forced to sing for them, and Telemachos vouched
for him, and also said they should spare the herald, if he not already
been killed. The herald then emerged from under an ox-skin under a chair,
where he had been hiding. Eurykleia rejoiced at seeing all the suitors
dead, but Odysseus told her to stop, that rejoicing over their deaths is
inappropriate. Odysseus told her to bring in all the women who had been
unfaithful to the household, and have them clean up the mess and wipe down
the chairs. The men took the bodies out. After the women had finished,
Telemachos and the other two took the women to a narrow place, and wrapped
a wire around all their throats and hung them (Odysseus had said to kill
them with the edge of the sword, but he decided that was too kind to
them). They kicked, but not for long. The three also took the rebellious
goatherd and cut off his nose, ears, and arms, and fed his private parts
to the dogs raw and left him (presumably to die). Eurykleia wanted to wake
Penelope, and to give him proper clothes, but Odysseus said not to wake
her, and that he wanted to sulfur the house first to clean it. After that
was done, she brought in all the faithful women, and they all cried, even
Odysseus, because he knew all of them.
Book 23:
The nurse Eurykleia woke up Penelope and told her that Odysseus was back
and had killed all the suitors. Penelope scolded her, but she said that
she had seen Odysseus’ scar earlier, and wanted to tell her, but Odysseus
prevented her. Penelope got up in joy, and went down and looked on the
stranger-guest for a long time. Then she said to bring his own bed for him
to sleep on out here. Telemachos said there was no woman so hard-hearted
as she was. But Odysseus got a little angry, and said that it would be
hard to bring his bed out, because he had made the bed post out of a tree
that had been growing where he built the room, unless someone had sawed it
off. This convinced Penelope, since no other man had seen their bed.
Odysseus had Telemachos get the singer to playing songs and had Telemachos
and the other two and the housemaids sing and dance, so people would think
it was a wedding. Then Odysseus and Penelope enjoyed themselves in love,
and then told each other their story, but Odysseus did warn Penelope that
Teiresias had said that he needed to find a wanderer on the mainland, make
sacrifices to Poseidon, come back and make hecatombs to all the gods, and
that he would die ignominiously at an old age. Athena prevented Dawn from
coming until she thought they had enjoyed lovemaking and sleep enough.
Book 24:
Odysseus told Penelope to stay upstairs and ignore any rumors, but he
needed to go. The four men went off to the villa of Laertes, his father,
where Odysseus found him attending to his excellent orchard, but dressed
poorly, in mourning. Odysseus decided to see if his father would recognize
him, so he asked why someone who clearly looked noble looked like a
thrall. Laertes asked who he was, and he gave an answer, and said he was
trying to find Ithaca, and a man who had guested five years prior. Laertes
threw dirt on his head and Odysseus could not take it any more and said
that he was actually his son. Laertes asked to him to prove it, and he
showed the scar and told the story, which satisfied Laertes. They waited
for Dolion and his sons, servants of Laertes, and they rejoiced to see
Odysseus back. Then they ate. Now the men of Ithaca held an assembly, and
Eupeithes, father of Antinoös, said that Odysseus had been an evil to
Ithaca: first he had taken the best men with him to Troy, and now, come
back after losing these, he killed the rest of the best men. But the old
prophet stood up, and in kind intention toward all said that they should
have listened to him and the previous assembly, when Telemachos requested
that they suitors leave, and told their sons to stop what they were doing;
now they paid the price for pursuing another man’s wife and eating up his
property. Half the men seemed to agree with him, but the other half went
with Eupeithes to attack Odysseus. Odysseus had three men with him
(Telemachos, Eumaios, and Philoitios), plus Dolion’s six sons, and even
the elderly Dolion and Laertes, all strapped on their armor for battle.
Laertes said he was happy, because his son and grandson were contending
over who had more courage. Athena told Laertes to throw his javelin, and
he killed Eupeithes. Then the twelve killed a number of the attackers.
Athena, in the form of Mentor, told them to stop, and the attackers turned
green with fear and fled. Odysseus, with a shout, went after the fleeing
men, but Athena told him to stop. Athena arranged that the others took an
oath of loyalty to Odysseus, who was now king again.